It sounds like it is getting air from somewhere other than your intake valve. Try closing off your intake and see if the temp keeps climbing, if so then it's drawing air.
I can close vents down and it may go up couple degrees, but kinda stays steady and of course Insulated it doesn't come down easy. I opened up door and used infrared and hit water pan and it was around 400deg, I put in a 14g diverted plate between charcoal basket and water pan and that helped alittle but still over a period of time she still slowly creeps
You mentioned it has a water pan. It could be that the water is getting lower allowing a higher temp, since it acts as a heat sync when used. I use thick steel on all my smokers and I start with a big fire to get them going then cut way back because the steel gets up to temp it doesn't require as much fuel to keep her hot. You could be experiencing the same. Verticals are a bit harder to get slowed down since you are actually putting the fire out rather than staving it for fuel, so I would try at the 2.5 hour mark start cutting back the air supply a little and you may find that it will plateau at the temp you want to run.
jm2cw
Current Smokers: Backyard RF Offset and Hybrid RF Offset trailer rig with Cowboy cooker and fish fryer, always room for more........
Thanks gonna keep playing with it, I don't use water, smoking right now, started it at 5:30am and it hit 200 about 6:10, I shut ball valve to about 1/4" opening and it's not at 8:30 and it's at 252, so hopefully it doesn't keep creeping past this point, I'm guessing when that 1/4" water pan starts to get hot it radiates some serious heat, but if I use a lot of water it boils so rapidly the temp never gets above 220, this things puzzling
The verticals I've cooked on like a Backwoods for example. I could only get it to temp right by using the water pan. I tried to cook without adding water and temps kept spiking.
jm2cw
I have heard some folks use sand in the water pan to stabilize the temp I don't have any experience with this myself. But that may work if the plate is radiating the heat.
Current Smokers: Backyard RF Offset and Hybrid RF Offset trailer rig with Cowboy cooker and fish fryer, always room for more........
As far as I know, all the verts that have been associated with smokerbuilder have not been insulated on the bottom. This solves the issue you are having. Pellet cabinets included. Totally insulted takes such a small fire once they are at temp, it's tough to control. Hence the water pan. I think this is why pitmaker uses a maze or form of minion method. Send us a pic of the fire basket and we can make suggestions as to what else may help.
That's very neat Creedt6, I do like that idea... a lot.
Learning generally boils down to "Repetition or the avoidance of pain", some people learn by doing, some by watching and some just have to pee on the electric fence.
Whether you think that you can, or that you can't, you are usually right. Henry Ford