That's what the forum is here for is to help anyone build a smoker that will perform just as you would expect. I'm not sure what pit calculator that you're using but I used the pit calculator on the forum to build my 24''x48'' and the throat (FB to CC) is 63 square inches. I also used a 4'' stack and it's about 32'' tall, just an inch or so longer than recommended. The 4'' between the BP and bottom rack is the same as mine, the range is 2''-6'' so you're right in the sweet spot. I ran your numbers through the pit calculator and it's only 80% of the recommended size, that's a huge difference. I'm not trying to discourage you but if the FB is too small it makes it very hard to maintain a constant temperature.
If you want to keep the same sized FB at least use the throat size of a recommended FB size, which would be ~60 sq in. That will at least maintain the airflow needed. Also, if you build it and then decide to mod a larger FB, the throat is good to go.
You should really use interior dimensions in the calcs.
If it's tourist season, how come I can't shoot 'em?
Sound like it will be a sweet unit when it's finished dude, can't wait to see it in action.
Also, you mentioned earlier that you don't want a lawn ornament, & please don't take this the wrong way, but there's one thing I've learned on this site is that when these guys suggest a change then it's only cause it's going to make the smoker work better. I know you said that this is how the Lang is built but there might be other factors in play with those ones, for example, a Jambo is built way different than most smokers & they usually out perform most smokers but that's cause Jamie understands convection & airflow & there's a few little things on his smokers that enhance those things. That being said, it's a good idea to enlarge the FB to 105-110% on the pit calc, just extend what you've already built, & the length of the stack is critical to the draw of the smoker. Trust me when I say you won't be sorry you did.
Thanks for the replies fellas. I agree with the 60 square inches for the throat. As far as enlarging the firebox I'm gonna stick with what I have for now. I'm wondering since part of the top of the firebox is actually inside the cook chamber does that aid in the heating of it.
I agree with everything I have heard about making things according to the pit calc. I have made one with too small of a firebox, I found that it was very hard to get up to temp, and if I wanted to bake a cake it was almost impossible to get to 350. I do also believe the FB being into the CC area some will help heat it, it will probably also make a hot spot on that end. The radiant heat pouring off the top of the raging FB will be very hot.
I have found that the smaller fire is much easier to control and keep steady. The larger FB is a box full of hot air that is easier to move than trying to run a big fire in a small box.
jm2cw
Current Smokers: Backyard RF Offset and Hybrid RF Offset trailer rig with Cowboy cooker and fish fryer, always room for more........
It does - primarily thought if it's in too far it creates a hot spot. I have this issue with mine so I'm thinking about installing a shadow plate.
Beating a dead horse here...fire box size has more to do with providing the right volume and maintaining proper air flow than providing more space for a bigger fire. This is another lesson I learned with my build. When I learned how small a fire it actually takes I reduced my fire basket size by probably 1/2 and I've had way better performance.
You're right. The cutouts won't be large enough. I shouldn't cheap out and I should just buy another plate, it's just money. I'd post a pic of my drawing but it's hard to see. I did a full size drawing on a piece of plywood. Let me try and get a good picture.
Should I stick with the smoker calculator numbers or go slightly larger. 46.6 is the throat size it's calling for. I'm at about 55 on the drawing. Thanks for all the help fellas
Learning generally boils down to "Repetition or the avoidance of pain", some people learn by doing, some by watching and some just have to pee on the electric fence.
Whether you think that you can, or that you can't, you are usually right. Henry Ford